« Attention, East Bay residents and businesses | Main | I think I may have found a lucrative sideline »

2008.05.15

Comments

mindy

Welcome to the club! Love, Massachusetts.

Jessica

Woooooo!!!!!!

Shotrock

I'm not surprised (well, okay, I work in the legal field, so I'm a bit inside baseball, admittedly). As Glenn Greenwald so succinctly explained in Salon:

The Court did not rule that California must allow same-sex couples the right to enter into "marriage." It merely ruled that if the state allows opposite-sex couples to do so, then same-sex couples must be treated equally. The Court explicitly left open the possibility that the state could distinguish between "marriage" (as a religious institution) and "civil unions" (as a secular institution) -- i.e., that California law could leave the definition of "marriage" to religious institutions and only offer and recognize "civil unions" for legal purposes -- provides that it treated opposite-sex and same-sex couples equally. The key legal issue is equal treatment by the State as a secular matter, not defining "marriage" for religious purposes.

Emphasis mine. What is going to inevitably happen nationwide is that the sort of church/state separation recognized by the Constitution in other areas (education, employment, etc.) will also be recognized in this area. Note that the decision did not use the term marriage OR civil union, but "loving long-term committed relationships." We will all, straights and gays, enter into a contractually-bound state-recognized "long-term committed relationship" through a civil license, which will function as today's marriage license does in the USA and as civil marriage does in countries of the EU. Then, we'll take that document and go to the house of worship of our choice for a religious marriage, should we so desire.

It's the only thing that's workable for this situation as we're probably going to live it, where states will come on board one by one for years before SCOTUS steps in (like what happened with interracial marriage). When that happens, the trailing states will be able to (read: forced to) implement universal civil licenses, and the on-board states -- whether they are GM states like MA or GCU states like NJ -- will be able to easily flip their systems to universal civil licenses.

In other news, as a die-hard Jersey Girl I'm ashamed to say that I'm gleeful to have a comeback to all the trash-talk from certain Californians about how the Golden State is always AheadoftheCurveblahblahMcTrendsettingcakes.

The comments to this entry are closed.

December 2008

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      

On twitter:

    follow me on Twitter